Sign in Subscribe
FIRE movement

Why Some People Quit FIRE – and What to Learn From Their Experiences

Eleanor Wilson

• 7 min read
Why Some People Quit FIRE – and What to Learn From Their Experiences
Why Some People Quit FIRE – and What to Learn From Their Experiences

The FIRE movement has captivated many with its promise of early retirement through aggressive saving and investing. However, not everyone who embarks on this journey stays the course. Understanding why some people quit FIRE and what lessons can be learned from their experiences can provide valuable insights for those considering or already pursuing this path. This comprehensive guide will explore the multifaceted reasons behind quitting FIRE, delve into detailed examples, and offer actionable lessons to help you navigate your own financial journey.

The FIRE movement has gained significant traction in recent years, encouraging individuals to save and invest a substantial portion of their income—often between 50% and 70% or more—to achieve financial independence and retire early. This movement has inspired many to rethink their approach to work, savings, and retirement, emphasizing the importance of financial freedom and the ability to pursue passions outside of traditional employment. However, the path to FIRE is fraught with challenges that can derail even the most dedicated individuals.

One of the primary reasons people quit FIRE is the rising cost of living and healthcare expenses. Many early retirees underestimate the cost of private health insurance before they become eligible for Medicare at age 65. The increasing healthcare costs and marketplace premiums in 2025 have made it difficult for some to sustain their early retirement plans. Let's explore this in more detail.

The Impact of Rising Healthcare Costs

Healthcare costs have been rising steadily, and this trend is expected to continue. For early retirees, this can be a significant financial burden. Consider a couple who retired early in their 40s with a substantial nest egg. They assumed that their investment portfolio would cover their living expenses and healthcare costs. However, they were caught off guard by the rising costs of private health insurance, which significantly reduced their disposable income. This unexpected financial burden forced them to reconsider their early retirement plans and return to work.

To mitigate this risk, it's crucial to factor in healthcare costs when planning for early retirement. Here are some strategies to consider:

  1. Research Health Insurance Options: Understand the costs of private health insurance in your area and factor them into your retirement budget. Look into different plans, such as Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs), Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs), and High-Deductible Health Plans (HDHPs), to find the most cost-effective option.

  2. Health Savings Accounts (HSAs): If you have a high-deductible health plan, consider contributing to an HSA. These accounts offer tax advantages and can be used to cover qualified medical expenses. Any unused funds can be invested and grow tax-free, providing an additional financial cushion.

  3. Telemedicine and Preventive Care: Explore alternative healthcare options, such as telemedicine and preventive care, to reduce overall healthcare costs. Regular check-ups and preventive measures can help avoid more significant health issues down the line.

  4. Health Insurance Marketplace: Familiarize yourself with the health insurance marketplace in your country. In the United States, the Affordable Care Act (ACA) provides subsidies to help individuals and families afford health insurance. Understanding these options can help you make informed decisions about your healthcare coverage.

The financial markets are inherently volatile, and those pursuing FIRE often rely on specific asset classes to achieve their financial goals. Market fluctuations can significantly impact the value of investments, leading to financial instability. This volatility can be particularly challenging for those who have retired early and depend on their investment portfolios for income.

For instance, an individual who retired early with a portfolio heavily invested in tech stocks may have faced significant losses during a market downturn. The decline in their portfolio's value could have jeopardized their financial security, prompting them to reconsider their early retirement plans. Diversifying their investment portfolio could have mitigated these risks and provided a more stable financial foundation.

To navigate market volatility, consider the following strategies:

  1. Diversification: Diversify your investment portfolio across various asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, real estate, and alternative investments. This approach can help reduce the impact of market downturns on your overall financial health.

  2. Asset Allocation: Determine your asset allocation based on your risk tolerance and investment horizon. A balanced portfolio that includes a mix of equities, fixed income, and alternative investments can provide stability and growth potential.

  3. Dollar-Cost Averaging: Implement a dollar-cost averaging strategy, where you invest a fixed amount of money regularly, regardless of market conditions. This approach can help smooth out the effects of market volatility over time.

  4. Rebalancing: Periodically rebalance your portfolio to maintain your desired asset allocation. This practice ensures that your portfolio remains aligned with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Balancing Frugality with Quality of Life

Extreme frugality, a cornerstone of the FIRE movement, can be challenging to maintain over the long term. Some individuals find that the lifestyle restrictions required to achieve FIRE are incompatible with their values or desired quality of life. Additionally, ethical concerns about investing and the emotional burden of extreme saving have led some to reconsider their commitment to FIRE.

For example, a person who has always valued travel and experiences may find it difficult to maintain a frugal lifestyle that restricts their ability to explore the world. The emotional toll of constant saving and deprivation can lead to burnout and a desire to pursue a more balanced lifestyle. Recognizing the importance of personal well-being and aligning financial goals with personal values can help individuals achieve a more sustainable and fulfilling path to financial independence.

To strike a balance between frugality and quality of life, consider the following strategies:

  1. Set Priorities: Identify your core values and priorities. Determine what aspects of your lifestyle are non-negotiable and allocate your resources accordingly. This approach ensures that you are not only working towards financial independence but also enjoying the present.

  2. Budgeting: Create a detailed budget that accounts for both your financial goals and your desired lifestyle. Allocate funds for experiences and hobbies that bring you joy, while still prioritizing saving and investing.

  3. Mindful Spending: Practice mindful spending by focusing on experiences and purchases that align with your values. Avoid impulsive purchases and instead invest in meaningful experiences that enhance your quality of life.

  4. Flexible Goals: Remain flexible with your financial goals. Recognize that your priorities and values may change over time, and adjust your financial plan accordingly. This adaptability ensures that your financial journey remains aligned with your personal well-being.

Exploring Alternative Approaches to FIRE

The FIRE movement has evolved to include various approaches, such as FatFIRE, which emphasizes early retirement with a comfortable lifestyle rather than extreme frugality. This shift reflects a growing recognition that financial independence does not have to mean complete early retirement but can encompass a range of lifestyle choices and financial strategies.

For instance, a couple who pursued FatFIRE may have focused on building a substantial nest egg that allows them to retire early while maintaining a comfortable lifestyle. This approach acknowledges the importance of enjoying the present while working towards long-term financial goals. By balancing frugality with quality of life, individuals can create a more sustainable and enjoyable journey towards financial independence.

To explore alternative approaches to FIRE, consider the following strategies:

  1. Define Your Version of FIRE: Determine what financial independence and early retirement mean to you. Whether it's extreme frugality, a balanced lifestyle, or a combination of both, tailor your financial plan to align with your personal goals and values.

  2. Leverage Multiple Income Streams: Diversify your income sources by exploring side hustles, passive income opportunities, and investment properties. This approach can provide additional financial stability and flexibility.

  3. Invest in Experiences: Allocate a portion of your income to experiences and hobbies that bring you joy. This investment in personal well-being can enhance your overall quality of life and make the journey towards financial independence more enjoyable.

  4. Continuous Learning: Stay informed about the latest trends and strategies in personal finance. Attend workshops, read books, and follow financial experts to expand your knowledge and adapt your financial plan as needed.

Lessons from Those Who Quit FIRE

The experiences of those who have quit FIRE offer valuable lessons for anyone considering this path. By adopting strategic saving and investing practices, planning for healthcare, balancing frugality with quality of life, and remaining flexible, individuals can navigate the complexities of the FIRE movement and achieve their financial goals.

Let's delve into these lessons in more detail:

  1. Strategic Saving and Investing: It is crucial to adopt a strategic approach to saving and investing. Diversifying your investment portfolio can help mitigate the risks associated with market volatility and economic fluctuations. This approach ensures that your financial plan is more resilient and adaptable to changing circumstances.

For example, an individual who diversifies their portfolio across various asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, real estate, and alternative investments, can reduce the impact of market downturns on their overall financial health. This strategic approach provides a more stable financial foundation and increases the likelihood of achieving long-term financial goals.

  1. Proactive Healthcare Planning: Proactive planning for healthcare expenses is essential. Understanding the costs of private health insurance and exploring alternative healthcare options can help ensure that healthcare expenses do not derail your financial plans.

For instance, a person who researches and compares different health insurance plans, considers health savings accounts (HSAs), and explores alternative healthcare options, such as telemedicine and preventive care, can better manage their healthcare costs. This proactive approach ensures that healthcare expenses are accounted for in their financial plan, reducing the risk of unexpected financial burdens.

  1. Balancing Frugality with Quality of Life: While frugality is an important aspect of the FIRE movement, it is equally important to balance extreme saving with maintaining a quality of life that aligns with your values and personal well-being. Finding a middle ground can make the journey towards financial independence more sustainable and enjoyable.

For example, a person who allocates a portion of their income to experiences and hobbies they enjoy, while still prioritizing saving and investing, can create a more balanced and fulfilling lifestyle. This approach ensures that they are not only working towards financial independence but also enjoying the present, which can increase their overall happiness and well-being.

  1. Flexibility and Adaptability: Financial independence is not a one-size-fits-all concept. It is essential to remain flexible and adaptable, adjusting your goals and strategies as needed to accommodate changes in your personal circumstances and economic realities.

For instance, a person who experiences a significant life change, such as a career shift, family responsibilities, or health issues, may need to adjust their financial goals and strategies accordingly. Remaining flexible and adaptable allows them to navigate these changes and continue working towards financial independence in a way that aligns with their current circumstances.

The FIRE movement offers a compelling vision of financial freedom and early retirement, but it is not without its challenges. Understanding why some people quit FIRE and learning from their experiences can provide valuable insights for those pursuing this path. By adopting strategic saving and investing practices, planning for healthcare, balancing frugality with quality of life, and remaining flexible, individuals can navigate the complexities of the FIRE movement and achieve their financial goals.

In conclusion, the journey towards financial independence and early retirement is not a linear path. It requires careful planning, strategic decision-making, and a willingness to adapt to changing circumstances. By learning from the experiences of those who have quit FIRE, individuals can gain valuable insights and create a more sustainable and enjoyable path towards their financial goals. Whether you are just starting your FIRE journey or have been pursuing it for years, these lessons can help you navigate the challenges and achieve the financial freedom you desire.

Also read:

Sign up for more like this.

Enter your email
Subscribe